ArticleComments [0]
An Experiment in Criticism (Canto Classics)
An Experiment in Criticism (Canto Classics)
C. S. Lewis
Cambridge University Press, 2012
152 pp., $19.99

Buy Now

David Neff


Escaping Ourselves

Why it is vital to teach students to read carefully.

icon1 of 2iconview all

My senior year in high school, I didn't read what the other kids read. I was an experiment. Our progressive high school administration wanted to see what would happen if they turned a few of their brightest students loose. And so I was cut loose.

It was the autumn of 1964, and Congress had just passed the Gulf of Tonkin resolution that handed President Johnson a blank check to use U.S. forces any way he wanted in Southeast Asia. In the previous 13 months, Bob Dylan had released two albums with the title tracks "Blowin' in the Wind" and "The Times They Are A-Changin.'" These tunes were mainlined into the bloodstream of American youth as I tried to decide what I would do with the loosely supervised study time my school had granted me.

How natural it was, then, that I chose to study Antigone, the 5th-century BC Greek tragedy about the clash between a determined individual's moral sense and the iron will of the state. My generation was in a mood to challenge the (obviously) immoral state in the name of our own (also obvious) moral sense.

And so, that year, I didn't read the poem, plays, and essays that my classmates read. Instead, I gathered a few theater junkies around me to tape Sophocles' tragedy on my oversized Ampex reel-to-reel recorder.

Was I richer or poorer for the experience? I was certainly enriched through my encounter with a classic work of literature that was still relevant after two-and-a-half millennia. But I was also impoverished for being ripped from my social context and having to mine for meaning without anyone else as a guide or a sounding board.

I recalled my feelings from that solo senior year a few months ago when I was introduced to the Common Core educational standards. There is nothing solo, idiosyncratic, or freelance about the Common Core State Standards. They were produced by representatives of state governors and their chief education officials, and they have been adopted by 44 states and territories. (No matter what critics say, this is not a federal intrusion into state educational responsibilities. It is a project of the states themselves.) Their purpose is to articulate a common vision of what it means for high school graduates to be ready for college. This includes, of course, the ability to read, absorb, and analyze texts—a series of intellectual and moral moves that the 16th century prayer book summarized as "read, mark, learn, and inwardly digest." Thus the English Language Arts standards carefully outline a progression in complexity from kindergarten to the end of high school that will help students develop the necessary abilities for an effective college experience.

One key reason for this joint effort across our state governments is that a student's zip code is currently one of the best predictors of college readiness. As in real estate, so in education: It's location, location, location. It is thus a matter of justice in our democracy to do what we can to overcome the handicaps created by the accidents of geography.

But my personal appreciation for the pedagogy the Common Core outlines and the texts it strongly recommends is that it can bring us back to the vision of Horace Mann, the pioneer of our Common School movement. Mann's major goal was training disciplined citizens. One of his key principles was that classrooms should pull together children from varied backgrounds, yet provide them with common understandings.

Mann aimed to establish schools with a common vision. The Common Core State Standards aim to help existing schools provide essential preparation for a diverse population. It is hoped that through a common experience with both literary and informational texts, students will gain insights and skills needed in order to rebuild the common foundations of our diverse society. Thus the recommended texts include key passages from Patrick Henry, George Washington, the Constitution, Abraham Lincoln, Franklin Roosevelt, Learned Hand, Margaret Chase Smith, and Ronald Reagan. All of these help us think beyond ourselves to engage a grand social experiment.

In his Experiment in Criticism, C. S. Lewis argued that "the necessary condition of all good reading is 'to get ourselves out of the way.' " We get out of the way of the text when we read it closely for what it has to offer. The Common Core Standards encourage such close reading. We get out of the way when we check our own interpretations in constructive dialogue with others. The Common Core Standards call for publishers to produce materials that "provide opportunities for students to participate in real, substantive discussions that require them to respond directly to the ideas of their peers."

One of my favorite pedagogues these days is James K. A. Smith, professor of philosophy at Calvin College. In his series-in-progress entitled Cultural Liturgies, he argues that human beings are not primarily thinking animals but must be regarded instead as "desiring animals." Head knowledge, especially head knowledge gained from an instructor who is "teaching to the test," is aimed at the wrong part of the moral anatomy to make good citizens. We need a pedagogy that "aims below the head," says Smith, in order to help students rightly order their loves and desires.

bottom_line
icon1 of 2iconview all
Most ReadMost SharedMost Commented


Seminary/Grad SchoolsCollege Guide